top of page


Hayes v. the United Kingdom: The ECtHR steps into stage two – and away from Vinter?
In Hayes and Others v. UK, the European Court of Human Rights has, for the first time, applied the second limb of the Sanchez-Sanchez test. The case marks a subtle but significant recalibration of the Court’s stance on irreducible life sentences, and appears to distance the extradition context from the more robust protections established in Vinter v. UK.
Giulia Borgna
Aug 15 min read


UK High Court blocks extradition to Albania on grounds of a flagrant denial of justice
The High Court has refused a renewed extradition request from Albania for an Albanian-British citizen accused of participating in a 1999 double murder. The Court held that returning the RP would expose him to a flagrant denial of justice, violating Article 6 ECHR, due to serious procedural failings in Albanian proceedings.
Giulia Borgna
Jul 202 min read


Hafeez v. the United Kingdom and the operation of Article 3 in the extradition context
The ECtHR miss the chance to clarify the extent of the revised approach to Article 3 issues regarding the imposition of life imprisonment...
Matteo Zamboni
Apr 24, 20237 min read


Estradizione: La Corte EDU sospende la consegna verso gli USA per violazione art. 3 CEDU
La questione del c.d. “imprisonment for life without eligibility for parole” è stata ed è tuttora oggetto di numerosi casi posti...
Walter De Agostino
May 1, 20213 min read


Bivolaru and Moldovan v. France: The first violation of ECHR as a result of the execution of an EAW
The case of Bivolaru and Moldovan is the first one in which the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR or the Court) found that the...
Matteo Zamboni
Mar 31, 202110 min read


Life imprisonment without parole as grounds to refuse extradition
As forcefully reminded by the Portuguese judge to the European Court of Human Rights in his dissenting opinion in the case of Öcalan v....
Matteo Zamboni
Mar 3, 20204 min read


Another "tale of two courts": The CJEU on prison conditions in the context of the EAW
With the judgment issued on 15 October 2019, in case C-218/18 (Dorobantu), the Grand Chamber of the Court of Justice of the European...
Matteo Zamboni
Nov 14, 201911 min read


The extradition of Sabrina De Sousa from Portugal to Italy
A new chapter of the Abu Omar Saga before the European Court of Human Rights With a decision of 7 February 2019, the European Court of...
Matteo Zamboni
Sep 10, 20192 min read


Romeo Castaño c. Belgio: l'obbligo di collaborare nella procedura MAE ai sensi della CEDU
Con sentenza del 9 luglio 2019 nel caso Romeo Castaño c. Belgio, che ho già commentato per EJIL Talk, la Corte europea dei diritti...
Matteo Zamboni
Sep 5, 20197 min read
bottom of page