top of page




eXtradando | Pills of the week 💊
A selection of recent developments in extradition, European Arrest Warrants and international judicial cooperation.
Redazione
1 day ago


Sentencing disparities and the EAW in Tagu (C-583/24)
Romania sentenced DZ to seven years for importing three grams of cannabis and four MDMA tablets, conduct that might have drawn only weeks in the Netherlands. In Tagu, the CJEU explains when a disproportionate sentence can bar surrender and why that disparity alone could not justify refusing the European arrest warrant.
Giulia Borgna
3 days ago


Asylum and extradition: what happens when the two procedures point in different directions?
Does an asylum claim, or even a grant of protection, prevent extradition? The Council of Europe’s renewed work on the subject is the starting point for a review of the different European approaches and the unresolved tensions in Italian case law
Giulia Borgna
Sep 27


The continuing validity of the foreign arrest warrant is a precondition for extradition
The Italian Supreme Court held that extradition cannot be authorised where there is unresolved uncertainty as to the authenticity or continuing enforceability of the foreign arrest warrants. The requested court must obtain targeted supplementary information rather than rely on generic assurances that the requesting State remains interested in extradition.
Giulia Borgna
Sep 17


The 1930 Treaty prevails over the Code: the Italian Supreme Court on extradition detention to Venezuela
The Italian Supreme Court held that the 1930 Italy-Venezuela Treaty’s 100-day detention period prevails over the 40-day domestic rule.
Giulia Borgna
Aug 30


Carla Zambelli’s second extradition case: why Italy’s Supreme Court remitted the case back for a fresh assessment
The Court of Cassation found no general bar to Zambelli’s extradition based on detention conditions, concerns over the impartiality of the judge or the alleged political nature of the offences. It held that the assurances were insufficient regarding the continuity of the specialist medical treatment she requires and remitted the case back for a fresh assessment.
Giulia Borgna
Jul 28


Bulletin (June 2026)
The most relevant decisions on extradition and the European arrest warrant (June 2026)
Redazione
Jul 14


What happens after refusing surrender: the Court of Justice in Rugu and Aucroix
In Rugu and Aucroix, the CJEU clarifies what must happen after an executing State refuses an EAW because surrender would expose the person to detention conditions contrary to Article 4 of the Charter. Refusal of surrender is no longer the end of the matter.
Giulia Borgna
Jul 9


Extradition to China after Liu: is Spain the last holdout in Europe?
Three years after Liu, European courts are increasingly treating extradition to China as a structural Article 3 problem, not as an ordinary cooperation file. This post maps the emerging case law, Spain’s exceptional reliance on Chinese assurances, and Beijing’s renewed efforts to keep extradition channels open.
Giulia Borgna
Jun 25


Why Italy refused extradition of former Brazilian deputy Carla Zambelli: a legal analysis
Italy refused Brazil’s (first) extradition request for Carla Zambelli, not because of her Italian citizenship or the political nature of the case, but because the conviction to be enforced raised a serious doubt about judicial impartiality.
Giulia Borgna
Jun 17


Bollettino (maggio 2026)
Le massime più rilevanti in materia di estradizione e mandato di arresto europeo
Redazione
Jun 10


Norway refuses surrender to Greece of human rights activist Tommy Olsen
Norwegian court goes past labels and looks at factual allegations. Surrender refused because solidarity is not a crime
Giulia Borgna
Jun 4


Khuzdar (C-95/24): il rischio di un livellamento verso il basso delle garanzie nel processo in absentia
Con la sentenza Khuzdar del 21 maggio 2026 (C-95/24), la Corte di giustizia interviene sul rapporto tra il rifiuto della consegna del soggetto radicato nello Stato di esecuzione e l’esecuzione della pena nello Stato membro di emissione, qualora la condanna sia stata pronunciata all’esito di un processo celebrato in assenza dell’imputato.
Giulia Borgna
May 31
bottom of page