top of page

eXtradando | Pills of the week đź’Š

Redazione
10 hours ago
5 min read

13-20 November 2026


A selection of recent developments in extradition, European Arrest Warrants and international judicial cooperation. This edition covers the CJEU’s ruling on disproportionate sentences, the significance of a previous refusal of extradition, detention conditions in France and Peru, sentence credits earned abroad, and the health risks associated with surrender.


🇪🇺🇷🇴 Disproportionate sentences and the European Arrest Warrant: the CJEU rules in Tagu

Court of Justice, Grand Chamber, Tagu, C-583/24, 3 November 2026

Seven years’ imprisonment for importing three grams of cannabis and four MDMA tablets into Romania. The same conduct could have attracted a sentence of just one to three weeks in the Netherlands.

In Tagu, the CJEU recognized that a serious breach of the principle of proportionality of criminal penalties under Article 49(3) of the Charter may, exceptionally, justify refusing execution of a European Arrest Warrant. However, it subjected that possibility to a demanding two-stage assessment, adapted from Aranyosi and Caldararu, requiring evidence of wider deficiencies in the issuing State’s sentencing system and a real risk affecting the individual concerned.

The Court found that the necessary deficiencies had not been established in Romania. Accordingly, it did not rule on whether the seven-year sentence was itself proportionate to the particular conduct.

The judgment raises important questions about the limits of mutual trust and the extent to which executing courts may scrutinize foreign criminal sentences.


🇮🇹🇻🇪 Can a previous refusal of extradition increase the risk of flight?

Italian Court of Cassation, Sixth Criminal Section, judgment no. 38653/2026, 30 September 2026

A woman sought by Venezuela for fraud had previously obtained a refusal of extradition from Spain, where the courts considered that surrender would expose her to a risk of violations of fundamental rights.

In subsequent extradition proceedings in Italy, that refusal became relevant for the risk of flight. The defence argued against pre-trial custody.

The Italian Court of Cassation upheld the decision maintaining custody in prison, noting that the requested person had no stable roots in Italy but maintained substantial personal and property connections with Spain. The fact that Spain had already refused her extradition reinforced the risk that she might return there to avoid surrender to Venezuela.

The defense also relied on the Spanish decision to challenge the permissibility of extradition. However, those objections, together with concerns about Venezuelan detention conditions, were declared inadmissible because they had not been raised before the Court of Appeal and could, in any case, be raised in the proceedings on the merits.

The Cassation ruled exclusively on the precautionary measure, not on whether extradition to Venezuela should ultimately be authorized.


🇮🇹🇵🇪 Extradition to Peru: foreign judicial orders and limitation periods

Italian Court of Cassation, Sixth Criminal Section, judgment no. 39630/2026, 13 October 2026

Can a judicial order issued by a foreign court interrupt the limitation period under Italian criminal law?

The Italian Court of Cassation answered that question in the affirmative in extradition proceedings concerning Peru, where the requested person challenged the expiry of statutory limitations for prosecution for alleged corruption offences.

The Court reiterated that limitation must be assessed separately under the laws of the requesting and requested States. However, a foreign judicial order may have interruptive effect under Italian law where it constitutes an autonomous decision of a kind recognized by the Italian limitation regime.

In this case, the Peruvian order replacing an earlier precautionary measure with custody in prison was regarded as an autonomous judicial act capable of interrupting limitations under Italian law.

The Court also examined assurances concerning detention conditions in Peru. The decision permitting extradition was upheld subject to safeguards concerning detention at AncĂłn II prison, or transfer to an institution offering equivalent conditions, together with guarantees addressing personal space, services and medical care.


🇮🇹🇫🇷 French prison conditions: domestic remedies are not enough

Italian Court of Cassation, Sixth Criminal Section, judgment no. 38932/2026, 4 November 2026

The existence of domestic legal remedies against inadequate detention conditions does not, in itself, establish that surrender under a European Arrest Warrant is compatible with Article 4 of the EU Charter.

In a case concerning surrender to France, the Italian Court of Cassation quashed a decision of the Genoa Court of Appeal which had relied on French legislative reforms and available domestic remedies without adequately examining updated evidence submitted by the defense.

That evidence included a decision by the Higher Regional Court of Koblenz, Germany, which had previously refused surrender of the same individual because of concerns about detention conditions in France.

The Cassation held that the Italian court was required to conduct an individualized assessment, taking into account the facilities in which the person would likely be detained, the relevant material conditions and any specific assurances provided by the issuing State, which in that case had not been requested. The Supreme Court held that the German decision was not binding on the Italian courts, but it constituted relevant material that could not simply be disregarded.

The case was remitted to another section of the Genoa Court of Appeal for a fresh examination.


🇬🇷🇮🇹 Transferring prisoners: what happens to sentence credits earned abroad?

Italian Court of Cassation, First Criminal Section, judgment no. 38651/2026, 29 September 2026, deposited 4 November 2026

A prisoner transferred from Greece to Italy sought recognition of more than 1,280 days of sentence credits already earned and quantified by the Greek authorities for work performed during imprisonment.

Under Greek law, the relevant mechanism allowed certain days spent working in prison to count double towards the sentence.

The Italian authorities disagreed over which court was competent to examine the request. The Court of Appeal of Lecce considered that it concerned a benefit analogous to Italian early release (liberazione anticipata) and, therefore, belonged before the supervisory judge (magistrato di sorveglianza). The latter disagreed, considering that the request concerned the calculation of the remaining sentence and fell, thus, within the competence of the execution judge (giudice dell’esecuzione).

The Cassation agreed with the supervisory judge.

Where a convicted person seeks recognition of benefits already acquired under the law of the sentencing State, the issue concerns the determination of the sentence remaining to be served in Italy. It, therefore, falls within the jurisdiction of the execution judge.

Requiring a fresh assessment under the Italian rules on early release could risk depriving the prisoner of benefits already acquired abroad or result in less favorable treatment. This judgment is relevant because it reaffirmed the importance of preserving sentence credits already acquired under the foreign legal system when responsibility for enforcement is transferred.


🇮🇹🇱🇺 Serious illness and surrender: treatment abroad is only part of the assessment

Italian Court of Cassation, Sixth Criminal Section, judgment no. 39631/2026, 10 November 2026

Assurances that adequate medical treatment will be available in the issuing State do not necessarily establish that a seriously ill person can safely be surrendered.

In a case concerning a European Arrest Warrant issued by Luxembourg, the requested person suffered from complex medical conditions, including significant cardiovascular problems. Expert evidence indicated that her clinical condition had not fully stabilized and recommended postponing a definitive assessment while further monitoring was carried out.

The Rome Court of Appeal nevertheless authorized surrender after obtaining assurances concerning healthcare in Luxembourg.

The Cassation quashed that decision, finding that the assurances did not adequately resolve the risks associated with the transfer itself.

Relying on the CJEU’s judgment in E.D.L. (C-699/21) and Italian Constitutional Court judgment no. 177/2023, the Court emphasized the need for an individualized assessment of the person's condition, including whether surrender could cause a rapid, significant and irreversible deterioration in health. The executing court must distinguish between risks that can be addressed through adequate arrangements or temporary postponement and those that cannot be excluded within a reasonable period.

The case was remitted to another section of the Rome Court of Appeal for a fresh assessment. No final refusal of surrender was ordered.


Comments


bottom of page